Has anybody a good example for a pawn-promotion to bishop?
I found one yesterday in German chess-magazine "Schach".
I will post it in the next days. (Just forgot to bring it to work)
Earlier I was sure that there's NO reason for a pawn to promte to bishop.
In this game I will post it is the easiest way to win. But not the only.
It is a grandmaster game. (the one with 2600+ lost against 2400+)
Please do not post problems.
Just real games.
Promotion to bishop
-
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Thu May 11, 2000 7:57 am
So here is the game:
![Image](http://www.net-chess.com/diagram.cgi/...........R..p......qk..p...p......bQ.p.......P..p....K.........jpg)
Black to move
W. Baklan (2606) - H. Pham Minh (2431)
Capelle la Grande 2004
Black would like to play:
c1 followed by Qe5+, Qg3+ and Bd3+.
But 1...c1Q (or 1...c1R) is not working because of 2. Rxg7+ Kxg7 3.Qg5+ and stalemate
1...c1N would be a problem because of Rd6
So:
1...c1B
2. Qxc1 Qe5+
3. Kg1 Qg3+
4. Kf1 Bd3+
0-1
![Image](http://www.net-chess.com/diagram.cgi/...........R..p......qk..p...p......bQ.p.......P..p....K.........jpg)
Black to move
W. Baklan (2606) - H. Pham Minh (2431)
Capelle la Grande 2004
Black would like to play:
c1 followed by Qe5+, Qg3+ and Bd3+.
But 1...c1Q (or 1...c1R) is not working because of 2. Rxg7+ Kxg7 3.Qg5+ and stalemate
1...c1N would be a problem because of Rd6
So:
1...c1B
2. Qxc1 Qe5+
3. Kg1 Qg3+
4. Kf1 Bd3+
0-1
-
- Posts: 29
- Joined: Fri Jun 30, 2000 6:40 pm
- Location: california
jsnyder: I think the point to the question was not whether promoting to bishop would be sufficient, but whether promoting to queen would be detrimental whereas bishop would be beneficial.
Gregorgysi: I'm going to have to play out your scenario on a board because when I go through it mentally trying to follow your depiction, I don't see how your 1...c1Q scenario with 2. Rxg7+ Kxg7 3.Qg5+ leads to stalemate where c1B would not if white followed the same moves...[/i]
I too have always thought that Knight would be the only potential piece to provide benefit over a Queen, and then only in very strange circumstances. I would have always thought that R or B could always be sufficed through a Q.
Gregorgysi: I'm going to have to play out your scenario on a board because when I go through it mentally trying to follow your depiction, I don't see how your 1...c1Q scenario with 2. Rxg7+ Kxg7 3.Qg5+ leads to stalemate where c1B would not if white followed the same moves...[/i]
I too have always thought that Knight would be the only potential piece to provide benefit over a Queen, and then only in very strange circumstances. I would have always thought that R or B could always be sufficed through a Q.
Underpromotion in Games
When I read gregorgysi's question I recalled that I once stumbled over an appropriate web site.
I've found it again:
Underpromotion in Games by Tim Krabbé
http://www.xs4all.nl/~timkr/chess2/minor.htm
CU, Joe
I've found it again:
Underpromotion in Games by Tim Krabbé
http://www.xs4all.nl/~timkr/chess2/minor.htm
CU, Joe
-
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Thu May 11, 2000 7:57 am
@sonrisante:
The difference between Q and B in the stalemate line 1...c1B 2.Rxg7+ is that after 2...Kxg7 3.Qg5+ the Bishop on c1 takes the queen so g1 is free for white's king.
@joelag:
Thank you for the link.
I should have known that Tim Krabbé has some material of it as he's specialized in chess curiosoties.
The difference between Q and B in the stalemate line 1...c1B 2.Rxg7+ is that after 2...Kxg7 3.Qg5+ the Bishop on c1 takes the queen so g1 is free for white's king.
@joelag:
Thank you for the link.
I should have known that Tim Krabbé has some material of it as he's specialized in chess curiosoties.
Here's a "miniature" example of where promotion to rook is the only winning move:
![Image](http://www.net-chess.com/diagram.cgi/.............P.k...............K.................................jpg)
White to move.
If White moves the king, black plays Kg7 and then captures the pawn next move -- draw.
If White promotes to queen, stalemate -- draw.
If white promotes to bishop or knight, insufficient mating material -- draw.
If white promotes to rook, however, Black must play Kg7, then white plays Rf1 or the like and goes on to mate with king and rook vs. king.
![Image](http://www.net-chess.com/diagram.cgi/.............P.k...............K.................................jpg)
White to move.
If White moves the king, black plays Kg7 and then captures the pawn next move -- draw.
If White promotes to queen, stalemate -- draw.
If white promotes to bishop or knight, insufficient mating material -- draw.
If white promotes to rook, however, Black must play Kg7, then white plays Rf1 or the like and goes on to mate with king and rook vs. king.